Case Reports

A company that submitted a tender for a towing contract with An Garda Síochána can proceed with an application for judicial review of the decision to award the contract to another company, after the Commissioner of An Garda Síochána was unsuccessful in its application to have the proceedings dis

The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has ruled that the UK discriminated against a transgender woman who was denied a pension on reaching the retirement age for women. The case concerned transgender woman MB, who was assigned male at birth in 1948, married a woman in 1974, began to live as a woman in

in separate proceedings with Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council (DLR) in 2013, and indicating that ILG expected to deliver a similar defence to the debt that was the subject of the default judgment. Mr Justice Barrett said that it was still unexplained why:

AIB Mortgage Bank have lost their application to the High Court in which they sought Ms Justice Baker to revisit her judgment in which summary judgment was granted in their favour, which they argued was liable to be misinterpreted and result in litigation chaos. In relation to the consideration of t

A man convicted of raping a 15-year-old family friend has successfully appealed his conviction over the trial judge's ruling preventing his lawyers from questioning the girl as to why she was on the contraceptive pill at the time. The girl had asserted that she was a virgin before her encounter with

A man who has been ordered for surrender to the USA to face child pornography charges has been unsuccessful in a bid to overturn failed judicial review proceedings, challenging the decision of the Minister for Justice and Equality to order his surrender under s.33 of the Extradition Act 1965. Dismis

The High Court has reserved judgment on whether further steps are to be taken in respect of two lawyers accused of misleading the court in an effort to stop the deportation of a Polish criminal. In a recent judgment, Mr Justice David Keane said lawyers for Thomas Bebenek had used litigation as a “

A Dublin pub has lost an appeal against the award of €5,000 to a customer who was accused by a barman of using a fake €10 to pay for a pint. Upholding the order of the Circuit Court, Mr Justice Michael MacGrath accepted the version of events as outlined by the plaintiff, and said that any privil

The Child and Family Agency has successfully appealed orders of the High Court which were made in regards to ongoing child abuse proceedings. The High Court had granted orders requiring the CFA to allow the respondent in the investigation to cross-examine the complainant in circumstances where the i

A 27-year-old woman who pleaded guilty to assaulting a man with head injuries in an unprovoked attack, has had her sentence reduced in the Court of Appeal. The woman appealed against the severity of her sentence of 12 years with the final 3 years suspended, submitting that her early guilty plea shou

A man who was sentenced to three-and-a-half years imprisonment for stealing a car with a heavily-pregnant woman in the passenger seat, has had his sentence increased in the Court of Appeal. The Court heard that the man had not given the pregnant woman any opportunity to get out of the vehicle, had r

A solicitor who was found guilty of professional misconduct by the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal has had her appeal dismissed in the High Court. The principal finding of misconduct was in relation to the transfer of €259,000 from a client account in breach of Solicitors Accounts Regulations 200

A woman who claimed that the father of her child had remained untraceable since causing a crash in which she was injured in 2011 has had her claim against the Motor Insurers Bureau of Ireland dismissed in the High Court. Describing the facts of the case as somewhat unusual, Mr Justice Anthony Barr w

A plumbing business has had its appeal against a decision of an employment tribunal unanimously dismissed after justices in the Supreme Court endorsed the decision of the tribunal, namely that the respondent was, inter alia, a worker in terms of the Employment Rights Act 1996. The Respondent, Gary S

The legal representatives of a Polish national who was served a removal order while imprisoned in 2015 have been ordered to pay the costs incurred by the State in judicial review proceedings brought on behalf of the man on the day before his scheduled removal in 2016. Stating that the legal represen