A man who was convicted of burglary has had his conviction quashed by the Supreme Court, on the basis that he had been deprived of a fair trial. Allowing the appeal, Justice Iseult O’Malley said that the defence was entitled to notice of the DPP’s evidence, and that “course taken by the prosec
Case Reports
A woman whose husband died over 30 years ago and has not had an Article 2 ECHR compliant investigation into his death has successfully argued that the decision of former First Minister, Arlene Foster, not to permit a paper on legacy inquests to go before the Executive Committee was unlawful. Directi
The Supreme Court has reversed the High Court’s finding that the unborn is a child for the purposes of Article 42A of the Constitution. Delivering a lengthy judgment from the seven-judge Court, Chief Justice Frank Clarke held that there was nothing in statute or common law to support the High Cour
DPD have successfully appealed a Court of Appeal ruling to the extent that the Supreme Court has substituted the award of €57,000 in interest payable to a former franchisee for a figure of €26,000. Writing in his judgment, Mr Justice O'Donnell endorsed the Court of Appeal of England and Wales de
The arbitration clause in the agreement between the Netherlands and Slovakia on the protection of investments is not compatible with EU law as it removes from the mechanism of judicial review of EU law disputes which may relate to the application or interpretation of that law. In 1991 the former Cze
A retired member of An Garda Síochána has lost an application for discovery of all documents considered by the Minister for Justice and Equality in a decision to refuse his claim for compensation. Stating that the issue arising in the judicial review proceedings brought by the former Garda was the
A man who was convicted of committing grievous bodily harm with intent has lost an appeal against his conviction, which he contended was unsafe due to irregularity in the trial judge’s taking of the jury’s verdict. Finding that the conviction was safe, Lord Chief Justice Declan Morgan was satisf
Stapleford Finance Designated Activity Company have been refused an application for summary judgment of almost €17m against a man who allegedly breached the terms of a deed of settlement which was agreed in 2014. Finding that Stapleford’s application did not satisfy the Aer Rianta threshold, Mr
A father and son who had €20,000 in cash seized by the Criminal Assets Bureau have successfully argued that the cash should have been excluded from evidence as it was unconstitutionally obtained on foot of an invalid search warrant. Ms Justice Iseult O’Malley emphasised that the Court should not
The daughter of a farmer whose inheritance of the family farm was awarded to her brother in the High Court on the basis of promissory estoppel has lost her appeal against the finding that the entirety of the lands should have been awarded. However, Mr Justice Michael Peart varied the order of the Hi
The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants has been granted an order setting aside judicial review proceedings which were brought against them by an Irish accountant. Describing the accountant’s experience as a “near never-ending nightmare”, Mr Justice Max Barrett found that the ACCA w
A doctor who was sanctioned with an “advice” due to a finding of poor professional performance has been unsuccessful in an application for judicial review in the High Court. The doctor sought orders quashing the sanction, and also submitted that the lack of a right to appeal the sanction was unc
A Precious Life protester who was served a number of Police Information Notes pursuant to the procedure on Police Response to Stalking and Harassment, has been refused judicial review in the High Court. Finding that the procedure for issuing PINs did not require the PSNI to seek the views of the per
An appeal by the Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police over the nature of the duty to investigate ill-treatment amounting to a violation of article 3 of the ECHR has been unanimously dismissed by justices in the Supreme Court. Lord Kerr gives the main judgment, with which Lady Hale agrees. Lord Ne
A man from Cork who was convicted of murder by a unanimous jury verdict has had his conviction quashed on appeal. Finding that the trial judge had erred in law in allowing the jury to visit the rubbish chute that the man had pushed the deceased into, Mr Justice Mahon said it was of greater concern t