Sat Lally: Reviewing a will drafted elsewhere? Three checks for Northern Ireland practitioners
More clients in Northern Ireland are arriving with wills made online or drafted in England. The documents usually look sound. Sat Lally explains where they most often rest on the wrong law and what to check before relying on one.
A familiar document with the wrong foundations
Online Will services tend to market themselves to “the UK”. Almost all of them draft to the law of England & Wales. When ClearLegacy set up a separate Northern Ireland service this autumn, we reviewed every clause and every piece of client guidance against Northern Ireland law before taking a single instruction. The exercise was humbling. Very little was obviously wrong. A great deal was quietly wrong.
The execution formalities explain why. Article 5 of the Wills and Administration Proceedings (Northern Ireland) Order 1994 follows section 9 of the Wills Act 1837 closely, so a Will drafted in England will usually have been validly executed here. The problems sit underneath that: in the statutes the document cites and in what the client was told it would achieve.
Check one: the trustee powers clause
Most England & Wales precedents refer to the powers of maintenance and advancement under sections 31 and 32 of the Trustee Act 1925, often extending them. That Act does not apply in Northern Ireland, where the equivalent provisions are in the Trustee Act (Northern Ireland) 1958.
The point is more than cosmetic. In England & Wales the Inheritance and Trustees’ Powers Act 2014 lifted the statutory limit on advancement from one half of a beneficiary’s presumptive share to the whole of it. That reform did not extend to Northern Ireland. A clause written on the assumption that trustees can already advance the whole share may give them less than the testator intended. Where full advancement is wanted, the Will should confer it in terms.
Check two: what the client was told about intestacy
Intestacy is rarely in the Will itself, but it shapes the decisions behind it. Clients often make or change a Will because of what they have read about who would inherit otherwise. Most of what they read describes England & Wales.
Under section 7 of the Administration of Estates Act (Northern Ireland) 1955, a surviving spouse or civil partner with issue takes the personal chattels, a statutory legacy of £250,000 and a share of the residue: one half where there is one child but only one third where there are two or more. In England & Wales the legacy is £322,000 and the spouse’s share of the residue is a half regardless.
On a £500,000 estate with two children, leaving chattels aside, an English explanation tells the spouse to expect about £411,000. In Northern Ireland the figure is about £333,000.
The gap is starker where there are no children. In England & Wales the spouse takes everything. In Northern Ireland, if a parent survives, a spouse in a £700,000 estate takes £575,000 and the parent takes £125,000.
A client who decided against a Will, or against a particular gift, on the strength of the English position may have been badly misled.
Check three: the guidance that comes after death
Family provision claims run under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) (Northern Ireland) Order 1979 rather than the 1975 Act. Grants issue from the Probate Office in Belfast. Neither point changes the Will itself. Both appear in the letters and guidance that accompany it. An executor handed English references starts out on the wrong footing.
A short review routine
When a client brings in a Will prepared elsewhere, three questions take a few minutes and catch most of the risk. Does the administrative powers clause cite the 1958 Act and grant any wider power of advancement expressly? Was the client’s understanding of intestacy, if it shaped the Will, based on the Northern Ireland figures? Does any accompanying guidance refer to the 1979 Order and the Belfast Probate Office?
None of this calls for a redraft in every case. It does call for asking where a Will was drafted and to which law before assuming that a document which looks right is right.

Sat Lally is the founder of ClearLegacy


