Reform urged over ‘ineffective’ witness attendance arrangements in NI courts
An inspection by Criminal Justice Inspection Northern Ireland (CJI) has found that large numbers of witnesses required to attend Court are not called to give evidence because defendants change their plea at a late stage or evidence is agreed close to a hearing beginning.
The report on witness attendance in criminal court proceedings published today, found men and women from our community, Police Officers, forensic scientists and other experts who attended Court as part of their job, were affected.
“All witnesses are central to the fair and effective operation of the criminal justice system. Their attendance enables Courts to hear evidence, reach decisions and deliver justice,” said James Corrigan, the Acting Chief Inspector of Criminal Justice in Northern Ireland.
Yet a file review undertaken by Inspectors of 30 prosecution cases found only 34 per cent of hearings proceeded as planned with late guilty pleas by defendants, cases not being ready to proceed and witnesses and legal representatives being unavailable identified as some of the contributory factors.
“Surveys carried out by Inspectors as part of our evidence gathering found that 60 per cent of Police Officers and forensic scientists who responded said they ‘rarely’ gave evidence at court and 16 per cent had ‘never’ given evidence. A similar CJI survey of members of the public who were also required to attend Court as a witness found that 55 per cent did not give evidence,” said Mr Corrigan.
“When cases do not go ahead as scheduled, witnesses may feel frustrated and anxious. They may have taken time off work and arranged childcare and travel to attend Court, only to be told at short notice that they are no longer needed. This can cause a loss of trust in the criminal justice system.
“A concerning finding was Police Officers who were detailed to attend court were routinely being taken away from frontline duties, with substantial costs incurred in terms of lost policing time and additional monetary costs,” he said.
During 2024-25, the number of hours attributed by the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) to Officer attendance at court equated to over 18,482 average working days, which CJI Inspectors calculated as costing over £4 million pounds based on pay scales for that year.
Mr Corrigan stated that the report recommends that: “the PSNI and Public Prosecution Service for Northern Ireland (PPS) should develop and implement an effective process to notify the PSNI’s Operational Planning Department when Police Officers are not required to attend Court” and that this should be done within the next six months.
Commenting on the report on BBC News Mr Corrigan added: “The delays within the system start at the investigation, they continue when the Public Prosecution Service needs to make a decision and those delays are then repeated in the courts, particularly in terms of adjournments.
“It’s a systematic problem we have in terms of slow, delayed ridden, criminal justice system and the people who are paying the cost are the victims and the witnesses.”


