NI: Executive cannot be compelled to legislate to protect young suspects’ identities

NI: Executive cannot be compelled to legislate to protect young suspects' identities

The Department of Justice cannot be compelled to legislate to protect the identities of minors who are suspected of crimes, the High Court in Belfast has ruled.

It follows a legal challenge by a 15-year-old boy who was identified in newspapers as a suspect in a cyber attack.

The Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999, which prevents under-18s being named in connection with alleged crimes, has yet to be commenced in Northern Ireland by the NI Executive.

Handing down his ruling, Mr Justice Adrian Colton said: “The respondent cannot be compelled to legislate on this matter.

“Given the wide margin of appreciation available to the state there is no basis for a finding that the measures in place amount to a breach of any positive obligation imposed under Article 8 or in domestic law.”

Share icon
Share this article: