Rape Crisis Ireland condemns Christian Brothers’ continued refusal to appoint nominee in survivors’ cases

Rape Crisis Ireland condemns Christian Brothers’ continued refusal to appoint nominee in survivors’ cases

Dr Clíona Saidléar

Rape Crisis Ireland has described the Christian Brothers’ continued position on legal claims by survivors of child sexual abuse as “a disgrace”, saying the congregation has not changed its stance in years.

The comments come as 314 former members have again been served with summons by way of newspaper advertisement as the Christian Brothers continues strategy of refusing to appoint a nominee that drew controversy in July when the case came before the High Court.

As the Christian Brothers is an unincorporated body a litigant must sue all relevant members unless a nominee is appointed. Current head of the Christian Brothers, Brother David Gibson, has refused to act as a nominee. As such when the case came before Ms Justice Mary Rose Gearty on 29 July she made an order that the names of 341 former Brothers be published informing them that they had been joined as defendants in the case. There is no allegation that these men were involved in abuse.

Brother David Gibson has stated that protracted litigation provides little benefit to claimants and that many claims are settled in a non-adversarial manner. He added that the Christian Brothers have provided compensation of over €40m, including legal fees, to over 200 claimants and provided counselling for survivors.

Rape Crisis Ireland has welcomed that the Christian Brothers has established a process for survivors who do not wish to go through the formal courts process. However, it said it is not for the congregation to dictate how survivors pursue justice.

Dr Clíona Saidléar, executive director of Rape Crisis Ireland, said: “This is a disgrace. The Christian Brothers have reiterated the position they took years ago; they have not changed course. We welcome that they have established a process for survivors who do not wish to go through the courts, but it is absolutely not for the congregation to dictate to survivors that they must pursue justice in the manner the offending institution decides and set aside their rights in the process. The level of paternalistic arrogance is breathtaking.”

“Survivors must be free to choose how they seek justice, including through the courts,” said Dr Saidléar. “A legal structure should not be used to control survivors’ access to their rights. The Taoiseach has called on the Christian Brothers to face up to their responsibilities, and the Tánaiste has described the treatment of survivors as despicable. We agree and we are urging the congregation once again to put forward a nominee. Let survivors decide how they vindicate their rights; they have waited long enough and they deserve justice.”

Join over 12,500 lawyers, north and south, in receiving our FREE daily email newsletter
Share icon
Share this article: