High Court: Court considers priority of adverse costs orders in liquidation

High Court: Court considers priority of adverse costs orders in liquidation

The High Court has confirmed that adverse costs orders rank in priority to liquidator remuneration.

Delivering judgment for the High Court, Mr Justice Michael Twomey concluded that there was no reason to doubt the plaintiff company’s ability to pay the defendant’s costs, having regard to “the fact that the joint liquidator, as an officer of the court, has provided sworn evidence that there will be sufficient funds to meet any adverse costs order, combined with the fact that he has a personal financial incentive to ensure that there are sufficient funds to meet any such adverse costs order.”

Background

The plaintiff company, Blackbee, was wound up by order of the High Court in May 2023. 

In August 2025, Blackbee issued proceedings seeking the recovery of monies which its joint liquidators alleged were due and owing from fundraising completed by Blackbee for the defendant company, Inua.

In June 2026, Inua issued a motion seeking security for its legal costs from Blackbee under s.52 of the Companies Act 2014 on the basis that adverse costs orders do not have priority over all other claims in liquidation and as such, Blackbee would not be able to pay its estimated €383,920.00 legal costs.

In this regard, Inua relied upon the change in wording between the provisions governing priorities on a liquidation in the now repealed Order 74, Rule 128 of the Rules of the Superior Courts and the provisions in s.617 of the 2014 Act currently in force, the latter of which refers only to orders made by the court in a winding up having priority, whereas the former referred to any order of the court having priority.

Opposing the motion, Blackbee contended that a successful defendant enjoys priority in respect of any costs order made in its favour against a company in liquidation. 

In this regard, Blackbee argued that the 2014 Act is consolidating legislation and if the legislature had intended to make such a fundamental change to the priority of adverse costs, it would have done so in explicit terms. 


The High Court

Mr Justice Twomey considered that the issue could be decided on the basis of the law regarding adverse costs in liquidation post the 2014 Act, as stated by the Supreme Court in Eteams International (In Liquidation) v The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland [2020] IESC 23.

The court had regard to paragraph 17 of Eteams, in which Mr Justice John MacMenamin stated that “when proceedings are being taken or defended by a liquidator in the name of the company rather than in his or her own name, he or she will have no personal liability for any award of costs that may be made in favour of the other party to the litigation, provided that there has been no personal impropriety on his or her part. The costs will, however, be classed as a cost or expense of the winding-up and will rank ahead of the liquidator’s own remuneration.”

Mr Justice Twomey highlighted the great injustice which would arise if a third party was sued unsuccessfully by a company in liquidation and if it did not get paid its costs in full by virtue of ranking pari passu with other unsecured creditors.

The judge also observed that the priority of adverse costs orders over a liquidator’s remuneration “means that there is a very significant personal financial incentive for liquidators not to waste the company’s money by taking proceedings indiscriminately against third parties.”

The court continued, “Since self-interest is a very strong motivating factor for everyone, this priority of an adverse costs order over liquidators’ remuneration offers considerable comfort to any third party who is sued by a company in liquidation.”

Mr Justice Twomey considered the evidence sworn by one of Blackbee’s liquidators to the effect that as of July 2026, Blackbee had €417,453.17 in cash at the bank, that realisations in the liquidation to July 2026 amounted to €2,189,852.14, with further realisations of €1.73 million expected before the end of 2026. 

The liquidator also gave evidence that the sum of €362,588.90 had been paid in respect of the remuneration due to the liquidators up to July 2023.  

Accordingly, the court reasoned that if Inua were to obtain a costs order and if there were insufficient funds in Blackbee to pay that costs order, then Inua would have the comfort of knowing that the joint liquidators would have to repay their remuneration of €362,588.90 paid to date to Blackbee for onward payment to Inua.

The court further considered that in addition to the liquidators’ remuneration, the sum of €417,453.17 in cash plus the net sum resulting from future realisations of €1.73 million would be available to meet any adverse costs order and the liquidators had indicated to Inua that they would retain sufficient funds in the liquidation to meet any adverse costs order.

   
Conclusion

Accordingly, the High Court concluded that there was no reason to believe that Blackbee would not be able to pay Inua’s costs if it wins the litigation.

Blackbee Investments Ltd (in liquidation) v Inua Hospitality PLC [2026] IEHC 765

Join over 12,500 lawyers, north and south, in receiving our FREE daily email newsletter
Share icon
Share this article: